« Make Money Betting on Enterprise Digg | Main | Details of Digg like Voting system for Wikipedia »

A Digg type tool can solve Wikipedia's problems

Wikipedia has been facing some credibility issues recently.

This is really easy to fix.

On every article, add a button that says - "Looks ok to me" and another one that says "I see issues here".

All registered users can click either button.

The results of this voting mean that each article can have a confidence indicator attached to it.

10 OKs and 5 Issues would give a 66% confidence rating.

If there are no edits since those people voted, then each vote gets a full weight of 1.

The value of votes degrades with edits. If you add information to the article, the vote weights only degrade a little. If you delete information, the value of past votes degrades quickly.

If a user finds an article with 100 votes and a 95 percent confidence rating, they know they can likely trust the article.

If users vote "I see issues with this article", they should be sent to a second page asking them to participate and fix the issues. If they do, they can change their vote to one of confidence.

It would be important to allow each user to have only one vote on an article, but to be able to change that vote as the article evolves. Something like "You voted OK, do you want to change that vote?"

Diggable

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.innovationcreators.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/59

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A Digg type tool can solve Wikipedia's problems:

» Wikipedia vs 投票 from Rauru Blog
A Digg type tool can solve Wikipedia’s problems, written by Rod Boothby, proposes an interesting method for Wikipedia’s quality control: digg.com style vote. Of course you can say it won’t work because an article will be edited durin... [Read More]

» Example – The success and structure of an open-source encyclopedia from Innovation Creators
Software certainly isn’t the only successful application of the open-source approach. One of the most interesting applications is Wikipedia. If you have not come across Wikipedia, stop reading this essay, open up a browser and go directly to www.wiki... [Read More]

Post a comment

Mandatory Head Shot

Rod_Boothby_Innovation_Creators.JPG

Please note: The comments expressed here on Innovation Creators are my own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of my employer. This site is only meant to be an open discussion about management approaches for encouraging innovation and related technology issues.

Subscribe

Check Out These Blogs

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33
Copyright © 2005 - 2006 - Rod Boothby - All Rights Reserved Performancing